Hoosier Mama Pie Company on Chicago Ave has pies for just about any occasion. There is plenty of space to sit and eat pie in restaurant at their bar or booths. If you need a little something with your pie they also offer full range of espresso and coffee drinks.
On Fridays you can get a flight of three different pie flavors for only seven dollars. If sweets aren't your style they also serve savory pies as well as quiche, yogurt parfaits and other breakfast options.